MCM Reputation - Historical

Applied By Justis R: Jan 9, 2019 at 3:37 AM

MCM Reputation

Old Version		New Version
1	[~~CENTER~~]	1	[template=title]text = Reputation[/template]
2		2
3	[SIZE=7]Reputation[/SIZE][/CENTER]	3	[INDENT]When negativity towards a business/person can be perceived as slander, and in a marketplace where everyone attempts to censor and silence others in their own best interest, it can be hard to know who it is you’re dealing with before entering into an agreement.
4
5	When negativity towards a business/person can be perceived as slander, and in a marketplace where everyone attempts to censor and silence others in their own best interest, it can be hard to know who it is you’re dealing with before entering into an agreement.
6	Holding people accountable for their past, and providing new users a channel dedicated to allowing them to understand who they’re interacting with, our reputation system provides MC-Market’s community a place to leave feedback about someone who’s done them right/wrong, or simply something notable that others should be aware of.	4	Holding people accountable for their past, and providing new users a channel dedicated to allowing them to understand who they’re interacting with, our reputation system provides MC-Market’s community a place to leave feedback about someone who’s done them right/wrong, or simply something notable that others should be aware of.
7		5
8	Rules governing the usage of this reputation system can be found [URL='https://www.mc-market.org/wiki/rules/']here[/URL], along with our other site rules.	6	Rules governing the usage of this reputation system can be found [URL='https://www.mc-market.org/wiki/rules/']here[/URL], along with our other site rules.
9	Always ensure that you’re keeping yourself up to date.	9	Always ensure that you’re keeping yourself up to date.[/INDENT]
10		8
11	[U]Reputation[/U] - The community’s collective opinion of a member as compiled by our reputation system.	11	[INDENT][U]Reputation[/U] - The community’s collective opinion of a member as compiled by our reputation system.
12	[U]Feedback[/U] or [U]Review[/U] - What is submitted in order to contribute to a member's overall reputation.	10	[U]Feedback[/U] or [U]Review[/U] - What is submitted in order to contribute to a member's overall reputation.
13	[INDENT]	13
14	[/INDENT]	12	[/INDENT]
15	[SIZE=5]Requirements[/SIZE]	13	[SIZE=5]Requirements[/SIZE]
16	[INDENT]	14	[INDENT]
...		...
26		24
27	When submitting feedback, pay attention to how you’re filling out the form.	25	When submitting feedback, pay attention to how you’re filling out the form.
28	If you find yourself doing any of the following, you can be assured that you are in violation:	26	If you find yourself doing any of the following, you can be assured that you are in violation:
		27
29	[LIST]	28	[LIST]
30	[*]You do not provide evidence for every claim you make.	29	[*]You do not upload evidence for every claim you make.
31	[*]You need to copy paste words or be unnecessarily redundant in order to meet the character requirement.	30	[*]Your listed transacted amount does not represent the value of one or more product/service transactions made between the two of you.
		31	[*]You find yourself needing to copy paste words or be unnecessarily redundant in order to fulfill the minimum character requirement.
32	[*]You fill up actions but not opinions, or opinions but not actions.	32	[*]You fill up actions but not opinions, or opinions but not actions.
33	[*]Your uploaded evidence ~~is an irrelevant imag~~e.	33	[*]Your uploaded evidence does not support the claims you’ve made.
34	[/LIST]	34	[/LIST]
35	Any feedback found to be abusing or misusing our submission format will be removed and the user issued warning points.	35	Any feedback found to be abusing or misusing our submission format will be removed and the user issued warning points.
36		36
37	If you can’t fully satisfy our form after an interaction, your interaction is not worthy of feedback. Don’t submit one.	37	If you can’t fully satisfy our form after an interaction, your interaction is not worthy of feedback. Do not submit one.
38	[/INDENT]	38	[/INDENT]
39		39
40	[SIZE=5]Relevance	40	[SIZE=5]Relevance
...		...
76	[/INDENT]	76	[/INDENT]
77	[SIZE=5]Additional Notes [/SIZE]	77	[SIZE=5]Additional Notes [/SIZE]
78	[INDENT]	78	[INDENT]
		79	A product/service transaction is not required for feedback, however, this is a marketplace, and most non-product/service related interactions will fail to be relevant enough to our community to satisfy the above requirements.
		80
79	If you are in the process of developing an opinion about a user due to an interaction, such as issuing them a loan and waiting on a return, you might consider leaving a neutral review explaining that they took out a loan with you and you are currently waiting on their return.	81	If you are in the process of developing an opinion about a user due to an interaction, such as issuing them a loan and waiting on a return, you might consider leaving a neutral review explaining that they took out a loan with you and you are currently waiting on their return.
80	This is relevant to the rest of the community who will want to know about a person’s current debts or commitments before entering their own business agreements with them.	82	This is relevant to the rest of the community who will want to know about a person’s current debts or commitments before entering their own business agreements with them.
81		83
Old Version		New Version

[CENTER]

[SIZE=7]Reputation[/SIZE][/CENTER]

When negativity towards a business/person can be perceived as slander, and in a marketplace where everyone attempts to censor and silence others in their own best interest, it can be hard to know who it is you’re dealing with before entering into an agreement.
Holding people accountable for their past, and providing new users a channel dedicated to allowing them to understand who they’re interacting with, our reputation system provides MC-Market’s community a place to leave feedback about someone who’s done them right/wrong, or simply something notable that others should be aware of.

Rules governing the usage of this reputation system can be found [URL='https://www.mc-market.org/wiki/rules/']here[/URL], along with our other site rules.
Always ensure that you’re keeping yourself up to date.

[U]Reputation[/U] - The community’s collective opinion of a member as compiled by our reputation system.
[U]Feedback[/U] or [U]Review[/U] - What is submitted in order to contribute to a member's overall reputation.
[INDENT]
[/INDENT]
[SIZE=5]Requirements[/SIZE]
[INDENT]
You must be a member of our site for [U]30 days[/U] before you are able to submit feedback on another user, however, you are still able to receive feedback during this time.

In order to submit feedback, you must be using your personal account. Business accounts are unable to leave feedback. Businesses do not have opinions, the people behind them do, please feel free to submit feedback through your personal accounts.
Lastly, you must not be presently restricted or suspended.[/INDENT]

[SIZE=5]Format[/SIZE]
[INDENT]
The format for submitting a review is set in place so that any feedback which is not able to naturally fulfill the format is able to be identified as not satisfying our expectations on a review's information requirements.

When submitting feedback, pay attention to how you’re filling out the form.
If you find yourself doing any of the following, you can be assured that you are in violation:
[LIST]
[*]You do not provide evidence for every claim you make.
[*]You need to copy paste words or be unnecessarily redundant in order to meet the character requirement.
[*]You fill up actions but not opinions, or opinions but not actions.
[*]Your uploaded evidence is an irrelevant image.
[/LIST]
Any feedback found to be abusing or misusing our submission format will be removed and the user issued warning points.

If you can’t fully satisfy our form after an interaction, your interaction is not worthy of feedback. Don’t submit one.
[/INDENT]

[SIZE=5]Relevance
[/SIZE]
[INDENT]One thing that will always be true of our reputation system is that submitted feedback on our platform needs to be relevant to our community.
An example of irrelevant feedback would be one of the following:

[INDENT][I]User doesn’t use energy saving lightbulbs and uses k-cups for their coffee.
User only showers once every week. That’s really gross.
User donated to a charity. They’re an awful person.[/I][/INDENT][/INDENT]

[INDENT]While the environment and hygiene are extremely important, they have no purpose as feedback on a marketplace platform where our community is mostly looking to interact with a user for online related business transactions. Keep the details relevant to the community who will be making use of your feedback or it will have no value and thus be in violation of our rules.

The last example, “User donated to a charity. They’re an awful person” provides an opinion which does not logically follow the basis, and thus has no value to our community.
Opinions about a basis are only relevant to others when their derivation are generally understood to be justified.
If your review does not follow the general flow of logic, it is irrelevant and in violation of our rules.

[/INDENT]
[SIZE=5]Dispute Process[/SIZE]

[INDENT]If you have received feedback which you believe to be untruthful or irrelevant, you may utilize our dispute system in order to make a case for having it removed.

To initiate a dispute on feedback you’ve received, visit its dedicated page, and select the [IMG]https://www.mc-market.org/styles/mcmarketv2/xencentral/trade/report.png[/IMG] button. This will prompt our [user=40]Bot[/user] to create a conversation between you and the user who submit the review with some instructions for how to continue in addition to marking the reputation as needing staff attention via our report system.
Do not add staff members to this conversation, the soonest available staff member will join on their own in order to support you.

Once the conversation has been created, you will want to provide a response which outlines why you believe the feedback is untruthful/irrelevant, and any supportive evidence you have to back your argument. [U]Any user who refuses to cooperate in a dispute will immediately lose the case[/U].
Always ensure that you’re communicating in a respectful and cooperative manner. [U]The best solution will always be that the two users involved are able to reconcile and resolve the issue on their own[/U].

Once a staff member becomes available, they will join the conversation and review the discussion that the two involved users have initiated, as well as the evidence and arguments laid out. If everything has been resolved and agreed upon between the two parties, there will be no further action necessary. Otherwise, the staff member may request more information in order to conclude what must be done in order to resolve and close the case.

The staff member will provide one of three resolutions after reviewing the case:
- The feedback is entirely rule abiding and will stay unless modified in the future in a way which is not.
- The feedback is partially rule abiding, but needs additions/removals/changes. These will be disclosed and a warning may be issued.
- The feedback is entirely rule violating, and has been removed. A warning may be issued.

If something is decided to be a violation of our rules, and it is re-added without a reasonable attempt to comply with the rules, a warning will always be issued.
Continuous refusal to cooperate will result in the complete revocation of a user’s ability to submit feedback via our reputation system.

[/INDENT]
[SIZE=5]Additional Notes [/SIZE]
[INDENT]
If you are in the process of developing an opinion about a user due to an interaction, such as issuing them a loan and waiting on a return, you might consider leaving a neutral review explaining that they took out a loan with you and you are currently waiting on their return.
This is relevant to the rest of the community who will want to know about a person’s current debts or commitments before entering their own business agreements with them.

[CENTER][SIZE=2]This page is subject to changes, check back periodically for updates.[/SIZE][/CENTER][/INDENT]

Log in / Register

Wiki

MCM Reputation - Historical